A white farmhouse style home with a charcoal standing seam metal roof under blue sky

Roofing Materials Compared

Explore the installation and upkeep tradeoffs behind asphalt, metal and low-slope roofing choices.

Free roof inspections. Clear repair and replacement options.

Request a free roof inspection

Tell us about the property and what you have noticed.

Roofing Materials Compared: the starting point

The right covering needs to fit the roof slope, structure and desired appearance. Comparing installed systems gives a clearer choice than comparing material prices alone.

Brick ranch home with gray shingle roof shaded by mature trees

Compare the Roofing Systems

MaterialUseful distinctionWhat needs planning
Architectural asphaltLayered shingle appearance with product-specific accessories.Slope, deck, underlayment, flashing and fastening.
Impact-rated asphaltA tested classification for a specific product.Installed-roof limitations, product instructions and actual insurance terms.
MetalPanel and profile choices with different attachment details.Movement, clips or fasteners, penetrations, trim and substrate.
Low-slope membraneA continuous surface with system-specific seams and flashings.Drainage, insulation, attachment and equipment curbs.

Metal Changes the Detail Plan

Metal roofing needs room for the movement of its selected panel system and compatible attachments. Walls, valleys, hips and penetrations need details designed for that covering. A shingle repair detail cannot simply be carried across unchanged.

Structure, slope and adjoining roof areas also matter. The replacement decision includes removal, the deck and water-shedding connections rather than just the visible panel.

Plan a complete replacement
Close-up of a metal roof panel clip and screw fastening standing seam panels together

Make the Material Choice Useful

Balance the roof conditions with what you want from the new covering.

Appearance

Profile, color and trim should be considered on the whole property, including adjoining roof sections.

Work and upkeep

Access, compatible repair materials and equipment service influence future care as well as installation.

Budget and coverage

Installed cost includes the assembly and details. Product and installation warranties need their actual terms, rather than assumptions from a material label.

Red brick ranch with black shutters and a dark gray shingle roof

Talk through the roof material decision

Request a free inspection. The existing roof and your preferred appearance give the conversation a useful starting point.

(816) 330-2235

Request a free roof inspection

Tell us about the roof and the property.

Call (816) 330-2235Request roofing help